10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes

Hosting an under-the-sea birthday party for your little mermaid? Check out these adorable mermaid cookie recipes that will make her the happiest mermaid of them all!

Mermaid Cookie Recipes

This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. For more information please read my full affiliate disclosure.

I think everyone goes through a mermaid phase at one point. I remember watching The Little Mermaid and wishing I could live under the sea and be a mermaid. My mother frequently called me a fish as I loved being in the water and swimming in the sea. I’m still a beach-loving gal so perhaps I’m part mermaid after all!

Either way, I love all of these beautiful and adorable mermaid cookie recipes that will delight mermaid fans of all ages!

Suggested Items to Make Mermaid Cookies

Several of the mermaid cookie recipes listed below require a few extra supplies to make.

Mermaid Cookie Cutters

Mermaid Sprinkles

Mermaid Cookies Pin 1

Too busy to make this right now? Pin for later to your favorite Pinterest Board!

You might also like…

Oreo Frog Cookies

Oreo Cookie Balls

Homemade Thin Mints

17 Crumbl Cookie Recipes

1
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
www.savvymamalifestyle.com
Mermaid Cookies Recipe: Perfect for a Kid’s Mermaid Party
These Mermaid Tail cookies are an easy treat to make for any themed party! They’ve got a sugar cookie base & frosted to your favorite colors.
Get the Recipe
2
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
thebearfootbaker.com
How to Make These Happy Little Mermaid Cookies
I love these Little Mermaid Cookies! Don't worry step-by-step instructions are provided!
Get the Recipe
3
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
www.sweetambs.com
Mermaid Tail Cookies with Royal Icing
I love the unique style of these adorable mermaid tail cookies!
Get the Recipe
4
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
www.thebakingchocolatess.com
Mermaid Cookie Bars
If you don't have a mermaid tail cookie cutter, try these mermaid cookie bars instead!
Get the Recipe
5
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
www.mimisdollhouse.com
Simple + Adorable Mermaid Cookies
These mermaid cookies are simple to put together and use candies to make the mermaid tail scales.
Get the Recipe
6
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
extremecouponingmom.ca
Mermaid Cookie Dip
Don't feel like making and decorating cookies, try this mermaid cookie dip instead!
Get the Recipe
7
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
amagicalmess.com
Mermaid Cookie Pizza Recipe
This mermaid cookie pizza is just the thing if you're looking to feed a crowd of little mermaids!
Get the Recipe
8
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
www.sweetambs.com
Mermaid Meringue Cookies!
Try these adorable and beautiful mermaid meringue cookies for a pretty twist on a mermaid cookie!
Get the Recipe
9
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
brooklynactivemama.com
The Most Adorable Mermaid Cookies
No special cookie cutter required for these gorgeous mermaid cookies!
Get the Recipe
10
10 of the Cutest Mermaid Cookie Recipes
amagicalmess.com
Mermaid Cookie Cups
These little cookie cups are filled with sparkly ocean colored frosting that's fit for all merfolk. Add these to your dessert table at your next mermaid party!
Get the Recipe

Where to Buy Mermaid Cookies

Don’t worry if you don’t want to make your own mermaid-themed cookies, there are plenty of amazing options to purchase mermaid cookies including personalized cookies!

Etsy has an excellent selection of mermaid cookies with several options to personalize these adorable cookies!

Amazon also offers a selection of mermaid-themed cookies but does not offer homemade or personalization.

Mermaid cookies are the perfect treat for anyone looking to add a little bit of magic and whimsy to their desserts. With their vibrant colors and ocean-inspired designs, these cookies are sure to impress at any party or gathering. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just starting out, there’s a mermaid cookie recipe out there that will suit your taste and skill level. So why not dive into the world of mermaid baking and see what kind of under-the-sea delights you can create?

About the Author

A picture of me, the owner of Chaos & Wine, with a variety of ingredients on a wooden table.

Hey! I'm April, the owner of Chaos & Wine!

I can't wait to share all my family's favorite recipes and a few random thoughts as a mom!

So let the chaos settle, grab a glass of wine and relax with me or join me for a little chaos in the kitchen!

You can find out more about me here!

This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. For more information please read my full affiliate disclosure.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top