Allspice Substitute – Easy 3-Ingredient Recipe

If your recipe calls for allspice and you do not have any, this easy allspice substitute uses three common pantry spices: cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves. Mix them together and use the blend in baking, desserts, fruit recipes and many savory dishes that call for ground allspice.

One important thing to know is that real allspice is not a spice blend. It is a single dried berry with a warm flavor often compared to cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves. This homemade version simply recreates a similar flavor when you need a quick replacement.

Pin

If you like keeping useful pantry shortcuts ready, this allspice alternative fits right alongside another homemade spice blend for fall baking. You can also keep a few homemade seasoning mixes ready for busy cooking days, or make a savory pantry blend too when dinner needs a quick flavor boost.

Why You Will Love This Allspice Substitute

• Only 3 ingredients: Cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves are all you need.
• Ready in 2 minutes: Measure, stir, and store.
• Great for baking: Use it in cakes, cookies, muffins, crisps, pies, and quick breads.
• Easy to scale: Make a small batch or double it if you bake often.
• Pantry friendly: It uses common ground spices you may already have.

Allspice Substitute Ingredients

Pin

You only need three ground spices for this homemade allspice substitute.

Ground cinnamon – Provides most of the warm, sweet flavor.

Ground nutmeg – Adds a slightly nutty, fragrant note.

Ground cloves – Adds deeper spice and should not overpower the blend.

How to Make an Allspice Substitute

1. Add the ground cinnamon, ground nutmeg, and ground cloves to a small bowl.

Pin

2. Stir until the spices are fully combined and the color looks even.

Pin

3. Transfer the spice blend to a clean spice jar or airtight container.

Pin

4. Store in a cool, dry cabinet for up to 2 months.

This is a stronger, more clove-forward version. For a milder substitute, use twice as much cinnamon as nutmeg and cloves.

How Much Allspice Substitute Should I Use?

Use this blend 1:1 for ground allspice. If your recipe calls for 1 teaspoon of ground allspice, use 1 teaspoon of the substitute.

If you have whole allspice berries, do not automatically replace them with this blend in pickling liquids or long-cooked dishes. Whole berries behave differently and can usually be removed before serving.

Recipe Tips

• Use fresh spices. Older ground spices lose aroma and flavor, so fresher spices make a better blend.
• Do not freeze it. Freezer moisture can ruin the texture and flavor of ground spices.
• Store it airtight. A small spice jar or mason jar works well.
• Label the jar. Add the name and date so you know when it was mixed.
• Use the same amount called for in your recipe. If a recipe needs 1 teaspoon ground allspice, use 1 teaspoon of this blend.

Grab your Free copy

Printable Jar Lid Labels

Get FREE printable labels for your homemade spices, jams and pantry gifts!

Grab them now!

Other Allspice Substitutes and Variations

• Softer flavor: Use a little less clove if you want a milder blend.
• Ground cinnamon. If all you have is cinnamon, it can work in recipes where allspice is not the main flavor, although the result will be sweeter and less complex.
• Pumpkin pie spice. This can work in many baked goods because it already contains several warm baking spices, but the exact flavor varies by brand.
• Whole allspice berries. If you have berries, grind them instead. This gives you real allspice rather than a substitute.
• Small batch: Make only 1 tablespoon total by using equal parts cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.
• Larger batch: Double or triple the recipe if you bake often during the holidays.

What Can I Use an Allspice Substitute In?

This homemade allspice substitute works best when allspice is one of several flavors in a recipe. Use it in:

• pumpkin and apple desserts
• spice cakes and cookies
• quick breads
• fruit crisps and pies
• mulled cider and warm drinks
• some meat rubs, sauces and stews

For recipes where allspice is the defining flavor – especially traditional Jamaican jerk seasoning – real allspice will give you a more authentic result.

Pin

How to Store This Allspice Substitute

Store the blend in a clean, dry, airtight spice jar at room temperature. Keep it away from heat, steam, and direct light. For the best flavor, use it within 2 months.

Pin

FAQs

Is allspice the same as mixed cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves?

No. Real allspice is a single spice made from dried berries, but its flavor is often compared to cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. That is why this blend works as a helpful substitute.

Can I use this in place of ground allspice?

Yes. Use the same amount of this blend as the amount of ground allspice called for in your recipe.

Can I make this without cloves?

Cloves are important because they give the blend its deeper allspice-like flavor. If you skip them, the blend will still taste warm, but it will not be as close to allspice.

How long does homemade allspice alternative last?

It is best within 2 months when stored in an airtight jar in a cool, dry place.

Can I use whole spices?

This recipe is written for ground spices. If you use whole spices, grind them finely before measuring and mixing.