A cocoa-kissed red cookie, a generous cream cheese swirl and a little red crumble on top. This Crumbl-inspired recipe starts with pantry ingredients, not cake mix. Let the cookies cool all the way before decorating.
Heat the oven to 350°F and cover two baking sheets with parchment paper.
Put the dough’s ½ cup softened butter in a mixing bowl with the brown and white sugars. Beat them together until the mixture is creamy, with no lumps of butter left.
Work the egg, vanilla, vinegar and red food coloring into the butter mixture until the color is distributed throughout.
Add the flour, cocoa powder, salt, cornstarch and baking powder. Stop mixing as soon as the dry ingredients have been incorporated; scrape the bowl to catch any dry pockets.
Use a ¼-cup scoop to divide the dough into 11 equal balls. Arrange them on the lined trays with 3 inches of space between them. You’ll save one baked cookie for the topping.
Press the portions into rounds about ½ inch thick, using your palm or the flat bottom of a glass.
Give the cookies about 10 minutes in the oven. Take them out while the centers still look a little soft, then leave them on their trays until completely cool. Don’t add frosting while any warmth remains.
To make the frosting, beat the cream cheese with the separate ½ cup softened butter until lump-free. Start the mixer on low as you add the powdered sugar and vanilla, then beat at a higher speed until the frosting is light and creamy.
Spoon the finished frosting into a piping bag fitted with a large round tip.
Choose one completely cooled, unfrosted cookie and break it into fine crumbs. This cookie is the topping, not an extra serving.
Swirl the frosting over the other 10 cooled cookies and finish each one with a sprinkle of the reserved crumbs.
Prevent your screen from going dark
Recipe Notes
Two portions of butter: The dough and frosting each have their own butter allowance. Keep them separate as you measure.
Gentle finish for the dough: Once the flour mixture has disappeared into the dough, stop the mixer and check the bottom of the bowl for dry patches.
Match the thickness: Aim for equal portions pressed to about ½ inch, rather than a tray of different-sized rounds.
A soft-looking middle is the cue: The cookies shouldn’t look firm all the way through when they leave the oven.
Cold cookies before swirls: Check for warmth before reaching for the piping bag. Cooling is required, but it has not been timed for this recipe.
Keep one cookie bare: Crumble it after cooling, then use those crumbs to decorate the ten frosted cookies.